Skip to content
  1. Home
  2. How We Rate Casinos

How We Rate Online Casinos

Before we score a casino, it must pass two checks: it pays out, and it holds a licence. Casinos that pass are tested with real money and rated out of 10 on six weighted criteria. This page sets out what we check, how much each part counts, how the final score is worked out and how often we check again.

+Read more

How online casinos are rated: criteria, tests and scores

Before We Score: Two Checks

A casino has to pass both of these checks before it gets a score. If it fails either one, we take it off our lists and don’t score it, however good its games or bonuses are.

  1. It pays out. A casino that doesn’t pay out winnings or withholds players’ money is removed and goes on our blacklist. A test withdrawal of ours that is refused or withheld counts too.

  2. It holds a licence. A casino with no licence at all is removed. A licence from any regulator passes this check, and where the regulator publishes a register, we look the casino up there instead of trusting the badge in its footer. How strong that regulator is counts later, in the Security score.

So every casino we list holds a licence from an overseas regulator. None can hold an Australian licence for online casino games: under the Interactive Gambling Act 2001, it is illegal for gambling providers to offer online casinos to people in Australia, and the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) lists online pokies and casino-style games among illegal online services. ACMA’s register of licensed providers is a register of Australian-licensed wagering services, not casinos.

The weighted score below applies only to casinos that pass both checks.

Our Rating at a Glance

Each casino that passes the two checks is tested with real money and scored on six criteria, each out of 10. The overall score is the weighted average of the six, rounded to one decimal place:

CriterionWeightWhat we look at
Security25%Which regulator issued the licence and whether we can confirm it, the company behind the casino, encryption and responsible gambling tools
Terms and conditions20%All of the casino’s terms: bonus rules, withdrawal limits, clauses that let it void winnings, fees and identity-check rules
Payouts20%Withdrawal methods, limits, processing times and fees, plus our own test withdrawal where we have made one
Games15%The range of pokies and table games, the studios behind them and the game information shown
Support10%How easy support is to reach and whether it answers the question
Usability10%Sign-up, finding your way around, the cashier and play on a phone

Step 1: Security Checks

Why the regulator matters

ACMA warns that an illegal service won’t give you the same customer protection as a licensed one, that Australian regulators can’t help if it withholds your winnings, and that blocked sites may stop you logging in to an existing account. If you have trouble getting money back from an overseas site, one of the options ACMA lists is to contact the relevant licensing authority.

What that authority can do varies. The Curaçao Gaming Authority, for example, says it doesn’t handle individual complaints against gaming providers and, as it is not a civil court, can’t order operators to compensate players; it adds that it may take action against an operator if a complaint or a pattern of complaints points to a possible breach of the law.

What we check

  • The licence and who issued it. We find the licence in the casino’s footer or terms, then look it up on the regulator’s own website. The Malta Gaming Authority’s licensee register can be searched by licensee name, authorisation status, URL or gaming service. The MGA also publishes a list of unauthorised URLs: websites it says it has no connection with, where any reference to an MGA licence is false and misleading. Entries dated September 2026 include several domains with “-au” or “-aud” in the name.

  • Curaçao licences. Under the National Ordinance on Games of Chance (LOK), in effect since 24 December 2024, the Curaçao Gaming Authority (CGA) is the regulator for online gaming; the CGA says that with the LOK the GCB is referred to by this name. Separately, Gaming Curaçao says it ceased operations on 18 August 2024, that all active sub-licences it issued under Gaming Services Provider N.V. 365/JAZ expired on that date and that all its seals were rendered inactive. So a Gaming Curaçao seal doesn’t show a current licence; we check which licence the casino holds now.

  • Who owns the casino. The company named in the casino’s terms, and whether it matches the licence holder.

  • Encryption. Whether the whole site, including sign-up and the cashier, runs over a secure (HTTPS) connection.

  • Responsible gambling tools. Deposit limits, time-outs and self-exclusion, and how easy they are to find and set. These matter more offshore: BetStop, the national self-exclusion register, doesn’t apply to online casino games. See how to block casino sites for other ways to keep yourself out.

Step 2: Real-Money Testing

Next, we use the casino the way a new player would, with our own money. For every brand we aim to:

  1. Open an account and go through the casino’s identity checks when it asks for them.

  2. Deposit real money: about A$5 to A$50, depending on the casino.

  3. Read the terms in full, not just the headline offer.

  4. Play pokies and table games, and look at the game information the casino shows.

  5. Contact customer support with real questions, such as how withdrawals and identity checks work.

  6. Request a test withdrawal and note how long it takes to arrive, any fees and any extra checks along the way.

What we find feeds the six scores below.

How Each Criterion Is Scored

Security (25%)

Every casino that reaches this stage holds a licence. Here we score what that licence is worth to you: which regulator issued it and whether we could confirm it on the regulator’s own register. The other checks from Step 1 count here too: the company behind the casino, a secure connection and responsible gambling tools you can actually use. It carries the most weight because it decides how much protection you have if something goes wrong.

Terms and conditions (20%)

We read all of the casino’s terms, not only the bonus offer:

  • Bonus terms: the wagering requirement and whether it applies to the bonus or to the deposit plus bonus, the time limit, the maximum bet while the bonus is active, any cap on winnings and which games count towards wagering.

  • Withdrawal limits: the minimum and maximum you can take out, per transaction or per period.

  • Clauses that let the casino void winnings, and how widely they are worded.

  • Fees: inactivity fees and any other charges on your account.

  • Identity-check (KYC) rules: when the casino asks for documents, which ones, and whether this is stated before you deposit.

How clearly all of this is written counts as well. As an example of why wagering matters, an A$100 bonus with 40x wagering on the bonus means A$4,000 in bets before you can withdraw. Our casino calculators can do this sum for any offer.

Payouts (20%)

We score payouts from what the cashier and the terms show: the withdrawal methods, minimum and maximum amounts, stated processing times and any fees. Where we have made a test withdrawal, our own result counts too: how long the money took to arrive, whether we were charged and whether extra checks appeared only once we asked for our money.

Games (15%)

The range of pokies and table games, the studios that make them, whether there is a live dealer section, and whether a game’s information screen shows its RTP. For figures on individual games, see our highest RTP pokies.

Support (10%)

Which channels exist (live chat, email or others), when they are open, how quickly someone replies and, most of all, whether the answer is correct and solves the problem.

Usability (10%)

How easy it is to sign up, find games, find the terms and the responsible gambling tools, use the cashier and play on a phone.

How the Final Score Is Worked Out

Each criterion score is multiplied by its weight, the six results are added up, and the total is rounded to one decimal place.

Illustration only. The scores below are made up to show the arithmetic; they are not the scores of a real casino.

CriterionWeightScore (out of 10)Points
Security25%82.0
Terms and conditions20%91.8
Payouts20%91.8
Games15%81.2
Support10%80.8
Usability10%80.8
Overall score100%8.4

8 × 0.25 + 9 × 0.20 + 9 × 0.20 + 8 × 0.15 + 8 × 0.10 + 8 × 0.10 = 8.4. A score of 8.4 falls in the 8.0 to 8.9 band: Very good.

What Our Scores Mean

The overall score is out of 10. This is how we read it:

ScoreWhat it means
9.0 to 10Excellent. Strong on all six criteria.
8.0 to 8.9Very good. A few minor weak spots.
7.0 to 7.9Good, with clear weaker areas. Check them in the review before you sign up.
5.0 to 6.9Average. Real drawbacks; read the review first.
Below 5.0Poor. Serious problems; we don’t recommend it.

A score describes the casino, not your chances of winning, and even a top score doesn’t change the legal position explained above. See Responsible Gambling for responsible gambling tools and free support.

How Often We Re-check

Bonuses, terms and payment options change. We re-check each brand monthly or quarterly, depending on the brand, and the score changes when our results do. If a re-check shows that a casino no longer pays out or no longer holds a licence, it comes off our lists.

How We Make Money and Stay Independent

PokiesPundit is free to read. We earn a commission when a reader follows one of our partner links to a casino and signs up or deposits. Casinos can’t pay for a score or a place in our lists.

We choose which brands to list ourselves, and every brand that passes the two checks is scored with the same six criteria and the same weights. For how commercial links are marked on our pages, see our Advertising Disclosure.

One brand has one score across the whole site. Our lists are mostly ordered by score, but where a brand sits on a page also depends on what the page is about: on our page about new casinos, for example, a newer brand can appear above one with a higher score.

In August 2026 Parliament passed the Interactive Gambling Amendment (Gambling Reform) Bill 2026, which includes a ban on commissions to staff or affiliates based on customer activity; most of its reforms start on 1 January 2027.

Who Does the Testing

All testing on PokiesPundit is done by one person, Jennifer McFadyen. She opens the accounts, makes the deposits, plays, contacts support, requests test withdrawals and scores each casino with this method. She also writes, fact-checks and publishes our pages.

Jennifer McFadyen, Slots Specialist & Content Reviewer at PokiesPundit

Meet Jennifer McFadyen

Jennifer McFadyen is a slots specialist and iGaming writer whose slot reviews and casino evaluations have been published on WhichBingo, TopRatedCasinos and Compare.bet. She breaks down how online pokies really work, from RTP and volatility to bonus features and game mechanics, and has worked across gambling markets including the UK, Malta, Canada, Australia and the US. At PokiesPundit she tests the casinos with real money and writes, checks and publishes every page.

Jennifer McFadyen | Slots Specialist

More about who we are is on our About Us page, and how we research and correct our pages is in our Editorial Principles.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which casinos don’t get a score?

Two kinds: a casino that doesn’t pay out winnings or withholds players’ money, and a casino with no licence at all. Both are removed from our lists, and a casino that doesn’t pay also goes on our blacklist.

Are the casinos you list licensed in Australia?

No. Under the Interactive Gambling Act 2001, online casinos may not be offered to people in Australia, so none holds an Australian licence for online casino games. Every casino we list holds a licence from an overseas regulator.

Does any licence count?

For the licence check, yes: a licence from any regulator is enough for a casino to be scored. It isn’t enough for a good score, though. Which regulator issued it, and whether we can confirm it on that regulator’s register, counts within Security, the criterion with the most weight.

What should I do if a casino you list won’t pay me?

Email [email protected], with screenshots if you can, and we will check the casino against the first of our two checks. For getting your money back, ACMA lists these options for overseas sites: independent legal advice, a complaint to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, or contacting the relevant licensing authority.

Can a casino pay for a better score?

No. Casinos can’t pay for a score or a place in our lists; the score comes only from the method on this page. How we do earn money is explained above and in our Advertising Disclosure.

Why isn’t a casino I know on your lists?

We decide ourselves which brands to list, so it may not have been tested yet, it may have failed one of the two checks, or we may have chosen not to list it. You can email [email protected] to ask about a casino.

Got a Question?

If you have a question about our ratings, or evidence that a score or a fact on our pages is wrong, email [email protected] or send us a screenshot. We check it and correct the page.

Latest from the community

Visit the forum (15 topics)